When it comes to online counselling vs in person, research shows both work about equally well for common concerns like anxiety, depression and stress. The better choice depends on you: online is easier to fit into a busy life and works from anywhere in the province, while in person gives you a separate, private space and suits people who find screens distracting or have no privacy at home. Many people use both.
Since 2020, video sessions have gone from rare to normal. If you are deciding how to start, here is an honest look at both.
Is online counselling as effective as in person?
For most people and most concerns, yes. Two large research reviews looked at this closely:
- A 2021 meta-analysis in Clinical Psychology Review pooled 57 studies and found that therapy by video produced results largely equivalent to in-person care across hundreds of outcomes (Batastini and colleagues).
- A 2021 meta-analysis in Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy concluded that therapy by video was no less effective than in-person therapy, with the strongest results for CBT treating anxiety and depression (Fernandez and colleagues).
What matters most in counselling is the relationship with your counsellor and the work you do together. That can be built on a screen or in a room.
Online counselling vs in person: side by side
| Factor | Online counselling | In person counselling |
|---|---|---|
| Effectiveness for anxiety, depression, stress | Comparable in research | Comparable in research |
| Travel time | None | Commute and parking |
| Scheduling | Easier to fit around work, kids, shifts | Needs a time slot plus travel |
| Privacy | Depends on your home setup | Built in, away from family |
| Body language | Face and upper body only | Full presence |
| Choice of counsellor | Any counsellor licensed for your province | Limited to who is nearby |
| Comfort | Some feel safer at home | Some feel safer in a neutral space |
| Tech needed | Phone or laptop and stable internet | None |
| Insurance coverage | Usually the same as in person | Usually the same as online |
When online counselling works well
- You have a long commute, irregular shifts or young kids.
- You live in a smaller town with few counsellors.
- You want a counsellor who speaks your language or understands your culture, and there is none nearby.
- You feel more open talking from your own space.
- You have mobility issues, chronic pain or a health condition that makes travel hard.
- You are recovering from a car crash and driving is stressful right now.
Online counselling is also helpful for couples who live or work apart. Our post on counselling for long distance couples covers that situation.
When in person counselling may be better
- You share a small home and can’t get privacy for an hour.
- You find it hard to focus on a screen, or video calls feel like work.
- You are working through trauma and want a separate, contained space to leave it in.
- You are in a relationship where someone at home monitors or controls you. Safety comes first, and an office visit may be safer.
- Your internet connection is unreliable.
- You simply like the ritual of going somewhere for your mental health.
Online counselling vs in person for couples
Couples counselling works well in both formats. Online sessions make it easier to find a time when both partners are free. Some couples prefer in person because it is harder for one partner to drift off or leave the call during a tough moment. A few practical tips for online couples sessions:
- Sit side by side on one screen, not on two separate devices in different rooms.
- Agree that phones go away.
- Plan 15 minutes after the session before jumping into chores or kids.
If there is any violence or fear of a partner, individual sessions are a safer starting point than joint sessions in either format. Learn more about couples counselling.
Can I see a counsellor online from anywhere in Canada?
Not always. Counsellors generally need to follow the rules of the province where the client is located during the session. A Registered Clinical Counsellor in BC can work online with clients anywhere in BC. If you live in another province, ask the counsellor directly whether they can see you.
How to get the most out of online sessions
- Find a private spot. A bedroom, a parked car or an office with the door closed.
- Use headphones. They improve sound and keep the conversation private.
- Test your link 10 minutes early. Charge your device.
- Turn off notifications. Treat it like an appointment, not a call between tasks.
- Have water and tissues nearby.
- Give yourself a buffer after. A short walk helps you shift back into your day.
If it is your first time in counselling, our guide to what to expect in your first counselling session applies to both formats.
Is online counselling covered by insurance?
In most BC extended health plans, online sessions with a Registered Clinical Counsellor are covered the same way as in person sessions. ICBC and CVAP funded counselling can also be done online. Our post on whether counselling is covered by insurance in BC explains what to check.
Online and in person counselling at Mind Matters Counselling
We offer both. In person sessions are at our office at 550 6th Street, Suite 240, in New Westminster, which is wheelchair accessible. Online video and telephone sessions are available for clients across BC. Counselling is available in English, Hindi, Punjabi and Urdu, and many clients switch between formats depending on their week.
We offer individual counselling, couples counselling and anxiety counselling. Call 236-868-6851 for a free 15 minute consultation and we can help you choose the format that fits.
Frequently asked questions
Is online therapy as good as in person therapy?
Research reviews show online therapy is about as effective as in person therapy for common concerns like anxiety, depression and stress. The counsellor relationship matters more than the format.
What are the disadvantages of online counselling?
The main downsides are privacy at home, tech problems, and seeing less body language. It may also not suit people in unsafe home situations.
Is online counselling private and secure?
Reputable counsellors use secure, encrypted video platforms built for health care. Your privacy also depends on choosing a private space at your end.
Can I switch between online and in person sessions?
Yes. Many counsellors, including Mind Matters Counselling, let you move between online and in person sessions as your schedule or needs change.
Is phone counselling an option?
Yes. Some people prefer phone sessions because they feel less self-conscious without a camera. Ask your counsellor if they offer it.
Sources
- Batastini, A. B., Paprzycki, P., Jones, A. C. T., and MacLean, N. (2021). Are videoconferenced mental and behavioral health services just as good as in-person? A meta-analysis of a fast-growing practice. Clinical Psychology Review, 83. doi.org/10.1016/j.cpr.2020.101944
- Fernandez, E., Woldgabreal, Y., Day, A., Pham, T., Gleich, B., and Aboujaoude, E. (2021). Live psychotherapy by video versus in-person: A meta-analysis of efficacy and its relationship to types and targets of treatment. Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy. doi.org/10.1002/cpp.2594
About the author: Navreen Kaur is a Registered Clinical Counsellor (RCC) with the BC Association of Clinical Counsellors and the founder of Mind Matters Counselling in New Westminster. She sees clients in person and online in English, Hindi, Punjabi and Urdu. Read Navreen’s full profile.

